site map | email us      Sudan shuts down local TEDx conference           |              Former IMF chief Strauss-Kahn in South Sudan to open bank           |              Slim in Sudan: Female fleshiness loses its allure           |              South Sudan Confirms Yau Yau Rebels Seized Town           |              South Sudan rebels overrun town           |           

Gienakie
AbdelGadir Salim

Weather on Your Site

 

     
THE WIRE
News Press Commentary
     
Southern Sudan: Building a New Nation


Southern Sudan: Building a New Nation
Cameron Sinclair -  January 01

Cameron Sinclair, Co-founder of Architecture for Humanity and the Open Architecture Network 

In seven days millions of residents in Southern Sudan have the opportunity to decide their future by voting for independence. The outcome is pointing towards a new nation state and the international community will rally around its birth. The real issue is whether the international community will help or hinder the development of Southern Sudan.

 

Adopting and Tackling Humanitarian Issues
The new nation, like many fragile states, will inherit a number of systemic issues. Ninety percent of the population live on less than one dollar per day. Approximately one in ten children do not make their fifth birthday and material mortality is the highest in the world. Southern Sudan doesn't only need doctors and clinics but an entire health care system. Then there is education. It is hard enough for a country to build a health system, try also having to build an education system, infrastructure and an economic base will be a monumental achievement. In an oil rich region, this should be the last place to be burdened with extreme poverty.

International NGO Involvement: Good or Bad?
The heavy handed approach by some well meaning international non-governmental organizations can spell disaster for a country trying to stand on it's own legs. In post conflict countries the international community steps in to help support a weak political and social system. The danger is when the international community unintentionally creates a 'hand to mouth' aid system that negates or overrides local small businesses and government initiatives.

Recently we worked in a city supporting a local low-cost health care business build and open a series of clinics. With a strong business model the clinics began to expand across the city only to find resistance from 'donor driven' clinics offering free services. Countries like Haiti have suffered from this competitive giving strategy. Where aid funding undermines economic incentive or a government's ability to develop local systems is dangerous and can lead to further destabilization.

Supporting Good Governance While Supporting Existing Government
Salva Kiir, voted in with 93% of the vote, will probably be the first president of Southern Sudan. How the world works with his government with make or break this emerging nation.

This is not a reboot. Academics and policy makers might have an idealized vision of starting a new nation but fragile states are never one borne from a clean slate. Most western states would not survive the sort of restrictions that get placed on developing countries in their bid to emerge out of poverty. We need to find ways to empower and support the new government without forcing predetermined notions of good governance.

Rule of Law
Beyond schools and health facilities the new nation state needs to support their governance with a strong rule of law. This is just not about police and judicial system but full accountability of aid and development -- for a new nation state, the biggest game in town. In our digital world it should be fairly easy to cross reference GIS mapping, crowd sourced information (using mobile technologies) and online accountability to create a more transparent system of aid.

Creating Communities Anchors
For the past decade community led or community-driven development has re-entered the rebuilding process. Those who look down on community involvement claim it allows weak local stakeholders the ability to disburse cash without proper oversight. This is a bit of a chicken and egg situation. There will always be a a number of bad apples but unless you are willing to trust local stakeholders there will never be local ownership of facilities. Given the percentage of aid siphoned off before entering local communities it's a little like complaining someone is taking the crust off the bread while tucking into a steak dinner. Communities need basic services, small business development and, in the case of Southern Sudan, agricultural innovation. Let's not tie down the community with heavy handed policy just to satisfy Western based reporting systems.

I'm not a policy wonk, nor an academic expert. I build communities, ones with integrated health and education facilities and woven together with economic avenues. Before we go in to build in Southern Sudan there must be a strong foundation, one that supports local governance and international collaboration. If you have ideas, thoughts or criticism, add them below.

 

Add Talk Back
 

 
Doe the death of JEM rebel Leader, Khalil Ibrahim means the death of JEM?
Not Sure
No
Yes
   View Poll Result


Latest SDB Posts
------------------------
 Enter Forum